Wednesday, August 26, 2009

The Gusty Photo - When Was It Taken?

[This is a series of comments I wrote for Palin's Deceptions.  There was a problem and not all of them were posted.  Since each post built on the other, I put them here as one long post.]

I agree with the people who have commented that Trig's birth date should be identified as alleged.  I also think that to keep with one of the objectives of the Palin's Deceptions site, which is to verify the accuracy of the evidence put forward, that the April 13 date for the Gusty photos would also have to be noted as alleged.  There are just too many questions around the photos to confidently be able to say that the pregnant Sarah was photographed on that date.   Their release on August 31, 2008 makes no sense.  Audrey has mentioned that people would have posted pictures of Palin after her nomination was announced, but the circumstances don't fit that explanation.  These pictures, at least the main part of the photos, were taken by people who were sympathetic to Palin - one even was hired by her to a position that required that Sarah could trusted him.    

Earlier release of the pictures would have been enormously helpful to Palin to dispel the rumours.  If they were released on the alleged date they would have been timely and provide a human interest angle of the pregnant governor finishing up the legislative session - definitely news worthy for the news station in question.  The footage and or pictures should have surfaced later in the week when Trig's birth was announced and there was no photo op with Palin and Trig - the very pregnant Palin would have been the closest image they would have.  It would also have linked well to the five week early birth - showing that this baby was ready to come out.  (By the way, I thought that Trig's announced expected birth date was in June, not May 23rd.  Can someone clarify this?)  The pictures would have been helpful after Trig's arrival was announced, when the rumours swelled up again.  By July, Bill McAllister was then Palin's press secretary, a reporter was asking questions about Trig's birth - releasing the pictures would have been a good idea and easily arranged by McAllister, who we know for sure was present three minutes and fourteen seconds after the picture of the pregnant Palin was taken.  Instead they didn't get a public viewing until Palin was linked to the McCain campaign.  

Recently, I have gone back and looked at the Gusty photos and thought about how they fit into this story.  There are problems with the what Palin is wearing, other than the sudden appearance, for the first and only time, of convincing padding indicating that money was spent obtaining a real pregnancy belly.  An investment which was not used later in the week when she flew to Texas.  (Should we assume that Palin was worried about her luggage being searched or  that she was too vain to appear that 'fat' when she was out of state trying to look pretty.   The other possibility is that the pregnancy belly hadn't been purchased at that time because Palin thought she could get away with it.  There is an enormous amount of contempt for the public shown in the slapdash way she padded herself - when she bothered to do it at all.)  What are other problems with how Palin dressed that day which doesn't fit in to the rest of the timeline.

1)  The shoes.  Take a look at them and ask yourself if you ever saw them before or any pair like them.  They are the shoes a pregnant woman would wear, if she was not Sarah Palin.  Throughout Palin's 'pregnancy' with Trig she wore heels when she wore dressy clothes. High ones - which would throw off her sense of balance, if she was actually pregnant.  If you wanted to believably make Palin look pregnant, the heels would have to go.

2)  The lack of Palin's trademark wrinkles.  In her clothes, not her face.  People may refer to her as a clothes horse, but she has only a passing relationship with an iron; the difficulty of getting clothes back and forth to the drycleaner turns out to be part of the break down of her marriage; and, after the election, we discovered that she stuffs clothes she isn't wearing into garbage bags.  All of this is easy to see if you review the pictures of Palin while she was 'pregnant ' and after, before she gets a wardrobe person to look after her clothes and she isn't as slovenly in her presentation.  The clothes in the Gusty pictures are too crisp and well maintained in comparison to these other pictures and these shots are alleged to be taken late in the day, once everyone has gone home, on the last day of the legislative session.  Instead the jacket looks freshly drycleaned and pressed and put on for the pictures.  Why is this the only time in her pregnancy that it look like someone helped her get dressed?

3)  Her hair is too well behaved.  Where is the bumpet or the back-teasing?  Sarah likes extra volume and it is missing here.  And, look again, in what other photo is her hair this neat?  Here it looks conditioned and hangs as a nice mass instead of fly away and tangled as in the other pictures.  Are you telling me that for once her hair behaved - at the end of the day for a quick interview that was so inconsequential it was never aired and for a few casual photos for someone else.  I noticed, as well, that it seems that in that period Palin left her hair down when she was too busy to put it up (or to pad herself) and dressed more casually on those days.  Oh yes, I have been wondering how her fringe bangs - the ones that soften her forehead - suddenly appear half an inch longer than the week before when they were freshly cut and hanging in a straight line well above her eyebrow.

4)  A sudden change in style.  The jacket is the same, but the purple top doesn't appear anywhere else and conveniently and clearly shows the round of the belly.  Throughout this period Palin wore black tops with the jacket. The scarf is suddenly gone as well. 

Now I am not sure when the pictures were taken of Andrea Gusty, and the camera databank isn't clear about that either.  However, the high probability is that the images of Palin, at least her body and hair, that appears in them were not taken on April 13, but some time afterwards when she had someone who could help her get dressed and do her hair.  Palin's behaviour is very consistent and she is not good at details; spending her own money on things she doesn't want - such as an empathy belly and sensible shoes;  putting effort in doing a convincing con; or following the advise of others.  Someone was helping her here and for once she was listening.

If you include the excellent photo analysis that the other Morgan performed on these pictures, it becomes clearer how these pictures probably came into being before they became public.

What do I think this, and the other inconsistencies surrounding these pictures, could possibly point to?

It is my belief that Sarah Palin conned the McCain team when they were doing their vetting process.  They would not knowingly risk everything, if they knew what Palin was really like, and they would be doing some due diligence to figure out if she would help them get elected.  Although they did not have enough time to do a proper independent vet of her, some vetting was done.  (Later they claimed they obtained one from the FBI, which the FBI subsequently denied doing.)  They would have uncovered certain things that they would have questioned Palin about when she came down to meet McCain before he announced her as a candidate.  Palin would have poured on the folksy charm and flirtatious manner.  They would have been impressed with her charisma, but realized she wasn't the smartest person in the room and thus tragically underestimated her cunning.  This is a frequent mistake when dealing with people on the psychopathic checklist.  Thinking that she would be grateful to be mentored by McCain and politically astute enough to get ahead by being a team player, they felt that they had someone to appeal to the right wing base of the party.  During the vetting questions, Palin, of course, would lie about everything, but at this point they didn't know that this is a defining trait of hers.

The rumours about Trig would have been brought up and she would have convincingly laughed them off.  (McCain's team was almost all men and they could have been taken in by the tight abs story, just as they wouldn't know why the wild ride story was next to impossible.)  There were no rumours, at that time, about Bristol being pregnant with Tripp, so they wouldn't have asked her about it.  When they asked her if there was anything they should know, which could come forward during the campaign and cause a problem, Sarah would have kept her mouth zipped.  (There are other issues that may or may not come up at this time, such as Todd being a member of the Alaska independence party which could have come up or not and Palin would have responded in the same way, but that is not part of our story right now.)

Having cleared the vetting process, there would have been brainstorming about how to handle what was seen as the few tricky issues.  The Trig pregnancy rumours would be one of them - perhaps the most pressing.  They would probably have asked her for Trig's birth certificate and Palin would have agreed that Todd could bring it with him (he would subsequently 'forget' it while getting the family ready to fly down).  This is similar to when Palin announced in a joint interview with McCain that she would produce her medical records and McCain, who by this time knew or strongly suspected the real circumstances, looked surprised.  One of Palin's tactics is to agree to produce something and then stonewall.  To the team, however, showing the birth certificate would be viewed as being on the defensive.  It would make far better political sense to have a picture, that showed an obviously pregnant Palin, quietly made available by someone who wasn't connected to the campaign.   Palin probably offered Bill McAllister's help on the project and Todd was told to pack the black jacket, which he definitely didn't forget.

Two to three more people had to be brought on board to pull this off.  A wardrobe person, who would easily and discretely be able to get her hands on an empathy belly, sensible pregnancy shoes, the purple top and black maternity pants.  Being a professional, she would have quickly had the jacket drycleaned and pressed.  She would also have kept Palin's hair neat after the the hair person had finished styling it earlier.  In keeping with being done by a professional, Palin's hair was properly washed and groomed; there was no back teasing.  A photographer was needed, who could also have done the photoshopping afterwards.  Or, that could have gone to a separate person.  

McAllister would have provided pictures and footage of Gusty that was either done earlier in the year and would work or he could, with the access his new position provided him, got the four of them into the legislation building after hours.  Everyone was probably excited by the news; willing, or pressured, to do a favour for McAllister in his new job; and, possibly, thinking it could lead to a more lucrative position, if everything worked out right.

There was an obvious problem.  Sarah Palin had been losing weight over the summer and her face was noticeably thinner than it was earlier in the year.  Morgan, in her analysis of the photographs, caught that when she found the pictures from that period where they lifted Palin's face from existing photos and put them in place on the new pictures.  One was a shot from the LA film shoot and I can't remember where the other one originated from.  If the pictures were staged in the spring, there wouldn't be a need to change the face.  Morgan also noticed that Palin's body was different than the rest of the picture and, in the uncropped interview picture, the perspective of the rug and wall didn't line up, which suggested the camera man possibly had to be moved to get the picture to work.

Once the pictures were deemed good enough - this would have been a rush job done in less then two days - the altered pictures were sent back to Alaska to discretely and quickly be uploaded on the internet.  Here people choked.  It was one thing to help out a former colleague, but quite another to be directly implicated.  There had to be plausible denial in case anything went wrong.  So the pictures went up on an anonymous account that had no other images on it. 

Does the above explanation of actions around the Gusty photos make it a conspiracy?  No.

I have learned through the years that jumping to conspiracies allows the individual on the check list to get off the hook.  These people work by exploiting others through manipulation and coercion.   The only people out of this group who would have known for sure that Sarah did not give birth to Trig would have been Sarah, herself, and Todd.  All the others, to various degrees, probably did not know and would not think that what they were doing was so bad because, in their minds, it wasn't deliberating covering the truth.  Nor would many of them be doing this for Palin.  On the McCain side they would be doing it because it was their job and for the party.  Gusty, the photographer, and the camera man probably did it as a favour to McAllister.  After working for Palin for two months McAllister was probably compromised enough that he felt compelled to go along.  What was he supposed to do?  Tell the McCain team that Palin had lied to them?  She would have fired him if he had done that or backed out in any way.  

Once they committed the first act of deception, wittingly or unwittingly, Palin would have a hold over them that she could use to coerce them into doing other things for her.  Such as the story that Gusty did later on about the pictures and Morgan's blog.

Besides, you have to be a team player to be part of a conspiracy and Sarah Palin has repeatedly shown that she is not capable of working with others.


  1. Vera,
    Now I am waiting for your responses to my questions!
    Joe Christmas

  2. Vera City -- I just found your site. I'm stunned that some of this did not appear in the PD site. I find it a very compelling analysis. It connects dots that have otherwise never been connected elsewhere.

    I always thought that the photos might have been made at the time stated, with the only fake part being the better belly. And then both Gusty and McAllister could claim all was kosher, even if they had their doubts. But that desn't explain, as your analysis does, the better hair, pressed clothes, more normal shoes.

    Now that I've found your great analysis, I'd like to hear more from you. Like: I never did understand what the Photoshop Morgan found that was so big that she was threatened out of web-existence. Do you know the details of the threat? My own fairly close look at these photos for Photoshop tracks did not reveal anything I could point to with certainty, so I concluded it prob was a real photo with the better belly. I never thought about it being taken at an entirely different time -- in part because I doubted that Gusty/McAllister would know and not talk.

    Well! Mainly I wonder what you are thinking about now, with all the recent info and non-info. I'm glad I found your site.

    I'm also wondering what Joe Christmas's qu are (in prev comment).

  3. Amy,

    I am trying to get back into the swing of this again it has been a busy time for me elsewhere. Morgan's contribution to this story was critical and threatened Palin. It deserves discussion on it's own entry. The key points before she was shut down was the photo analysis that Palin was not pregnant, that the Gutsy photos were photoshopped, and the letter from Palin's doctor was altered significantly.

    Thanks for commenting it motivates me to start posting again.


  4. Just found this blog~and truly enjoy reading it. Amazing what some will do for "power"....just absolutely amazing.

  5. I always wondered. This other Morgan..what was the name of her website? Is it still online (archives)? What time period did she have the site up? It always seemed like it was referred to as right after SP was selected and before Audrey got going. I came upon PD around the holidays after election.

  6. Say NO to Palin in PoliticsJanuary 31, 2010 at 10:56 AM

    Well done Vera. I can see how this could be and probably was done.

    I wonder how Scarah convinced them that she had no good pics of her while prego. Wouldn't they have to wonder about that?

    Do you think the McCain staff did a search first? then realizing there was no sufficient proof, they then decided to create this pic as insurance?

    Do you think Scarah made up stories about why there were no pics? like she avoided having them taken for political reasons. like she didn't want to make a big deal out of a gov having a baby. she wanted to keep it low key. I can see her saying that.

    With a time crunch, I can see them buying that BS and like you said, they thought okay, then we take one now and pretend it was then. after all, they thought she really did have Trig, so like you said everyone involved would have been okay with this to a certain degree.

    Now they are all in this together, lol. uh oh, kinda messy, and now looks pretty darn underhanded if it comes out. It would hurt all their political careers, except Scarah could blame it on the McCain campaign making her do it. But it would still make her judgement look questionable.

    Glen Beck thinks Scarah is shrewd, I do too.

    It's also freaky, @ 7:47, Beck says Scarah told him she's really focusing on Obama, that she's zeroing in on him and watching his every move, like a hawk.

    I think it's safe to say she's obsessed with him, she hates him, he stole her presidency and she's going to do everything she can to take him down. So she's basically stalking him in a political sense looking for a crack in his armor, forget about everything else, it's all a distraction, go for the lead wolf.

    I do not like this woman, or how she must think. I'm glad others can see it. It's hard to imagine how she thinks, it hurts my brain, lol, but she is fairly predictable.

    She loves being viewed as the underdog, I think that feeds her drive. I think her false sense of entitlement via god also gives her a keen sense of timing, in a psycho way. That is why we can not underestimate this woman.

    I think in one way she likes being underestimated and ignorant because that gives her an edge, no one on the opposing team will take her seriously or watch her too closely. Then she'll come from behind, sneak up and steal the play.

    But I also think it hurts her self esteem and feelings to be outed about her lack of intellect, hurt she probably turns into anger which is now directed toward her goal, her priority, and that is taking down this President. If she can do that, she's the hero, winning the game for the team.

    Then I wonder where she would direct her sick obsession, to taking down and conquering competing countries?

    listen to this radio broadcast....@ 5:52

    Keep writing!

  7. Say NO to Palin in Politics,

    Whew, there is a lot there. To just respond to one point that you put forward:

    "Do you think the McCain staff did a search first? then realizing there was no sufficient proof, they then decided to create this pic as insurance?"

    Here is a passage from Game Change that Gryphen posted on his site a week and a bit ago:

    'On page 366 and 367 it mentions the McCain camp's concern about the rumors that Trig was Bristol's, and not Palin's son.

    "Before the announcement, most of the members of Team Palin couldn't have picked their new boss out of a lineup or properly pronounced her name. They had no answers to even the most routine questions about her."

    By the time Palin arrived in St. Paul on Sunday night, August 31, there were plenty of queries. What foreign countries had she visited? Had she ever been to Iraq? Had she really killed the infamous Bridge to Nowhere in Alaska, as she claimed? Did she worship at a Pentecostal church where people spoke in tongues? Had Todd been arrested for driving drunk? Had her son, Track, been busted for drugs? And, most incendiary of all, was her infant son, Trig, who had Down syndrome, really her baby--or was he Bristol's?"

    "On Monday, the embattlement of the McCain press shop reached code red. To stamp out the Trig rumors--whipped up by photos on the Internet showing a supposedly very pregnant Palin looking remarkably svelte--Sarah and Todd acknowledged that Bristol was expecting, and therefore couldn't be the five-month-old baby's mother."'

    His post is here:

    This fits with what I have written here that the first people Sarah Palin was conning was the McCain team. By the time they found out they had been had it was too late. Before that, their growing feeling of being in "Code Red" could lead to the theory that I outlined.

    Palin producing the pregnant Bristol after her selection was confirmed, thus scamming the McCain team, also supports my feeling that Palin went rogue on Bristol's dress at the RNC. When I look at the pictures of Bristol, prior to her outing, she is always draped in a baby blanket and holding Trig. Sarah would have tried to stop the wardrobe people from measuring Bristol for clothes while she was still hiding her pregnancy from the McCain team.